England’s Ashes campaign faces intense scrutiny following Perth defeat

England’s cricket team will be held accountable if their preparations for the 2025-26 Ashes series fail to pay off, according to BBC chief cricket commentator Jonathan Agnew. Following a crushing defeat in the first Test in Perth, Agnew has questioned whether England’s current approach under Ben Stokes and Brendon McCullum is fully suited to the challenges of Australian conditions.

Controversial Preparation Plans

Ahead of the series, England considered sending some players to Canberra to play against the Prime Minister’s XI as a warm-up. However, the squad sent – Jacob Bethell, Josh Tongue, and Matthew Potts – were all fringe players who did not feature in the first Test and are unlikely to play in the upcoming second Test in Brisbane.

Agnew noted:
“England’s original plan was not to send anyone for the game against the Prime Minister’s XI, so little has changed. Key batsmen like Zak Crawley, Joe Root, and Harry Brook will be off to Brisbane to bat in the nets.”

The commentator stressed that England – including players, management, and administrators – will be judged on their preparation and performances throughout the Ashes series.

---

Lessons From Perth

England’s first Test innings lasted fewer than 70 overs combined, highlighting the team’s struggles against a dominant Australian bowling attack. Agnew described the defeat as:
“The worst I have seen an England team perform in a Test in this country. They should have won. Instead, the game was tossed away calamitously and feebly.”

Despite the heavy loss, Agnew emphasized that England’s players are committed and physically prepared. “Stokes told me his team works hard, and I cannot disagree. They are supremely fit,” he said, noting that Matthew Potts appeared as disciplined as a military operative during training.

However, preparation alone is insufficient if the team is not focused on the right strategies. England’s aggressive approach under Stokes and McCullum, praised initially for revitalizing the team, has shown limitations against stronger opposition. In their past 14 Tests, England have more defeats than wins, with seven losses to six victories.

---

The Role of Technique and Accountability

Agnew pointed to England’s batting approach as a critical factor in their defeat. Reckless shot selection, particularly by Harry Brook, contributed to early collapses. Comparing Brook’s innings to the controlled aggression of Travis Head, Agnew highlighted a need for maturity and technique in challenging conditions.

He also noted a perceived lack of accountability within the England setup, a concern echoed by former Australian players. “’That’s the way we play,’ is a mantra of this England team and it is one of their failings,” Agnew explained.

Preparation deficiencies, such as only playing a single warm-up match against the Lions, contributed to predictable dismissals in Perth. Edges outside off stump and failed attempts at powerful drives underlined the importance of adapting to Australian pitches and pink-ball conditions.

---

Fan Frustration and Team Morale

England supporters have expressed genuine anger following the Perth defeat, with Agnew acknowledging the financial and emotional investment fans make in following the team. However, he stressed that players do care deeply about their performances.

For instance, Zak Crawley, dismissed for a pair, was visibly dejected after the match, countering narratives suggesting England players are indifferent. Agnew defended the team’s approach to off-field activities, including golf and leisure, noting that mental recovery is important alongside intensive training sessions.

---

Looking Ahead to Brisbane

Despite being 1-0 down, England still have an opportunity to reset in the second Test at the Gabba. Agnew stressed the importance of learning from Perth and applying lessons in Brisbane, where results will carry significant weight. A 2-0 deficit would place careers under scrutiny.

“This England team will have gone through the same disappointment in Perth and should now be determined not to repeat it in Brisbane,” he said. England must refine their preparation, focus on disciplined batting, and adapt strategies to challenge Australia’s formidable day-night Test team, including star bowler Mitchell Starc.

Agnew concluded that accountability will define England’s Ashes campaign. Success or failure will hinge not just on effort, but on intelligent execution of technique, strategy, and team cohesion.