Comedy stars Meg Stalter and Paul W. Downs stole the spotlight at the 31st Annual Critics Choice Awards on January 4, 2026, with a hilarious red carpet twist: they cosplayed as Kylie Jenner and Timothée Chalamet. Their eye-catching ensembles were near-identical replicas of the orange Chrome Hearts outfits the celebrity couple wore at the Los Angeles premiere of Marty Supreme in December 2025.

Red Carpet Comedy: Stalter and Downs’ Bold Fashion Choice

Stalter, 35, and Downs, 43, arrived at Barker Hangar in Santa Monica, California, wearing striking orange outfits designed by L.A.-based designer Erica D. Schwartz.

• Paul W. Downs mirrored Chalamet’s look with a bright orange leather suit, orange silk shirt, and matching boots. He even carried a black leather ping-pong paddle case over his shoulder, just like Chalamet.
• Meg Stalter channeled Kylie Jenner in a floor-length orange gown featuring triangular cutouts below the bust and waist, a cross embellishment, and orange pumps. She accessorized with a cross necklace, completing the look.

The cosplay was both a tribute and a comedic nod to the couple’s previous red carpet appearance, showcasing Stalter and Downs’ flair for playful, over-the-top fashion statements.

Chalamet and Jenner’s Original Look

Chalamet, 30, and Jenner, 28, originally wore their coordinated outfits at the Marty Supreme premiere on December 8, 2025, marking their second red carpet outing together as a couple. Dating since spring 2023, the pair previously made headlines at the 70th David Di Donatello Awards in Rome, where Chalamet received the David for Cinematic Excellence.

For the premiere:

• Chalamet opted for a sleek velvet suit with a boutonniere.
• Jenner stunned in a curve-hugging Schiaparelli Fall/Winter 2025 gown with a plunging neckline, accessorized with a velvet clutch and statement Schiaparelli earrings, including intricate hand-shaped designs.

Their second matching red carpet appearance had already captured global attention, making Stalter and Downs’ cosplay instantly recognizable.

Meg Stalter: A History of Red Carpet Statements

Stalter is no stranger to bending red carpet norms. At the 2025 Emmys, she subverted formal dress codes by wearing straight-leg blue jeans, a white Hanes T-shirt, black flats, and sunglasses, paired with a black handbag labeled “cease fire!” likely referencing the ongoing Israel-Palestine conflict.

She told Variety at the time:

“I think people need to bring back jeans on the red carpet… There’s no rules. You’re allowed to do what you want.”

Her latest Critics Choice Awards ensemble continues her legacy of combining comedy, social commentary, and fashion risk-taking.

Red Carpet Reactions and Coverage

Stalter and Downs’ cosplay immediately became a fan-favorite moment, highlighting their comedic chemistry while paying homage to pop culture icons. With their meticulous attention to detail and playful energy, they managed to turn a star-studded awards night into a viral moment for fashion and comedy fans alike.

The 31st Annual Critics Choice Awards aired live on E! and USA Network from Barker Hangar, featuring a mix of heartfelt tributes, award presentations, and red carpet highlights—including the unforgettable Stalter and Downs cosplay.