Filmmaker Abhinav Kashyap, known for his directorial hit Dabangg and for his candid, often controversial opinions about Bollywood, has once again sparked a wave of discussion within the industry. This time, Kashyap has turned his attention to Aamir Khan, one of the most respected and celebrated actors in Hindi cinema. In a recent interview with Bollywood Thikana, Abhinav did not mince words, describing Aamir Khan as “sabse chalaak lomdi”—literally “the most cunning fox”—and alleging that the actor manipulates filmmakers, collaborators, and industry insiders to maintain control over his projects.

Abhinav Kashyap has never shied away from expressing his grievances publicly. His previous clashes with the Salman Khan family, particularly over the Dabangg franchise, garnered widespread attention and highlighted the undercurrents of tension in Bollywood’s tightly knit creative circles. Now, with his remarks on Aamir Khan, Kashyap has once again thrust himself into the spotlight, igniting debates about power dynamics, creative control, and the politics of the Hindi film industry.

Allegations of Manipulation and Perfectionism

According to Kashyap, Aamir Khan’s reputation as a perfectionist in the industry goes beyond meticulous attention to detail—it veers into manipulation and overreach. In his interview, he stated, “He’s the most cunning fox. He’s even shorter than Salman. But what a manipulative man he is, and the most clever thief.” Kashyap claimed that Aamir has perfected the art of identifying weaknesses in collaborators and using charm, social gatherings, and indulgences to bend situations in his favor. “He finds weaknesses by seducing important people, throwing parties, indulging in debauchery, drinking alcohol, and feeding them food,” Kashyap alleged.

Abhinav went on to suggest that Aamir’s involvement in projects can be creatively draining. According to him, Aamir “drains out” directors, writers, and other collaborators by being excessively involved in every stage of filmmaking—from scripting to shooting to editing. “He takes 25 takes of something; his first and last takes are the same. He doesn’t understand acting, and there’s not even that much difference in his performance,” Kashyap asserted, painting a picture of an actor whose pursuit of perfection may come at the cost of his collaborators’ creative energies.

Such statements strike at the heart of a longstanding debate in Bollywood: the fine line between rigorous perfectionism and control that borders on authoritarianism. Aamir Khan, widely praised for his dedication and commitment to authenticity, has often been called a “methodical perfectionist.” Yet, Kashyap’s remarks suggest that this meticulousness may sometimes translate into manipulative or overbearing behavior in collaborative environments.

Industry Influence and “Trapped” Creative Minds

Kashyap did not stop at describing Aamir Khan’s methods on set; he extended his claims to the actor’s influence over some of Bollywood’s most respected creative minds. “He’s manipulated me a lot in his ad films and works through very powerful people. He’s trapped some of the industry’s most prominent intellectuals, including Prasoon Joshi and Rakesh Omprakash Mehra. I respect them a lot, but I don’t know what hold he has over them,” Kashyap stated.

Prasoon Joshi, a renowned lyricist, and Rakesh Omprakash Mehra, a celebrated filmmaker, have collaborated with Aamir Khan on multiple projects over the years. Kashyap’s remarks hint at the perception that Aamir’s influence may extend beyond individual projects, creating a network of creative professionals who operate under subtle pressures or strategic alignments. Whether these claims hold merit or are a reflection of Kashyap’s personal experiences, they add another layer to the ongoing conversation about power hierarchies and influence in Bollywood.

The Context: Kashyap’s Fallout with Salman Khan

To understand the gravity of Kashyap’s current statements, one must consider his history within the industry. Kashyap’s previous public fallout with Salman Khan and disputes surrounding the Dabangg franchise marked him as a polarizing figure in Bollywood. After directing the blockbuster Dabangg, which catapulted Salman Khan to renewed stardom, Kashyap faced alleged creative disagreements and contractual disputes with the actor and his production team. The fallout made headlines, portraying Kashyap as both bold and controversial, willing to challenge industry giants openly.

His remarks about Aamir Khan, coming shortly after the public discussion of his issues with Salman, suggest a continuing pattern of candid—if contentious—commentary. While some audiences and industry observers perceive his statements as bold truths about hidden workings of the Bollywood machinery, others view them as part of a larger pattern of public grievances from a filmmaker whose professional relationships have often been fraught with tension.

Reactions and Industry Speculation

Kashyap’s recent comments have divided audiences and insiders alike. Some see them as an unfiltered exposé of the power dynamics and hierarchies that often influence filmmaking decisions in the Hindi film industry. Others dismiss them as personal attacks fueled by past grievances, reflecting more about Kashyap’s experiences than about the actors he critiques.

The controversy also sheds light on the broader issue of creative collaboration in Bollywood. Filmmaking, particularly on large-scale projects, is inherently a collaborative endeavor, often involving multiple creative personalities with strong opinions and visions. When strong-willed actors like Aamir Khan enter the equation, balancing artistic control, vision, and collaboration can be challenging. Kashyap’s allegations raise questions about how creative control is exercised and negotiated in an industry where star power can heavily influence the final product.

Aamir Khan’s Public Persona vs. Kashyap’s Allegations

Aamir Khan’s public persona has long been that of a meticulous and socially conscious actor who prioritizes quality and authenticity in his work. Known for immersing himself deeply in roles and often taking years to finalize a project, Aamir has cultivated a reputation for discipline and rigor. His approach to cinema has earned him accolades, commercial success, and a devoted fan following.

Kashyap’s characterization, by contrast, paints a picture of an actor whose perfectionism crosses into manipulation, exerting subtle pressure on collaborators to align with his vision. While the public has largely celebrated Aamir’s commitment to excellence, Kashyap’s allegations invite scrutiny and discussion about the balance of power and creative autonomy in high-stakes filmmaking.

Conclusion: Bold Commentary in Bollywood’s Shadowed Corridors

Abhinav Kashyap’s remarks about Aamir Khan, following his long-standing feud with Salman Khan, underscore a recurring theme in Bollywood: the tension between creative freedom, star power, and professional relationships. While Kashyap frames his critique in terms of personal experience and observation, the statements have broader implications for conversations around collaboration, influence, and accountability in the industry.

Whether one views Kashyap’s comments as courageous truth-telling or as another episode in a personal feud, they undeniably highlight the challenges filmmakers often face when navigating the complex hierarchies of Bollywood. From manipulating project control to influencing creative collaborators, Kashyap’s interview presents a stark perspective on how star power can shape careers, projects, and artistic expression.

As the controversy continues to make waves, it serves as a reminder that behind the glamour and box-office success of Bollywood lies a web of relationships, rivalries, and power dynamics that often remain hidden from public view. In this landscape, Abhinav Kashyap’s unfiltered commentary not only generates headlines but also forces the industry and its audiences to confront the realities of influence, ambition, and creative tension in one of the world’s most prolific film industries.

---