Pakistan Enacts Historic Military and Judicial Reform
Islamabad, Pakistan – In a landmark move, Pakistan has enacted sweeping military and judicial reforms with the ratification of the 27th Constitutional Amendment. Signed into law by President Asif Ali Zardari on Thursday, the amendment introduces major changes to Pakistan’s higher judiciary and its military command structure, sparking widespread debate about the future of civil-military relations in the country.
The amendment passed both houses of parliament amid protests and criticism from opposition parties, civil society groups, and members of the judiciary. While its impact on the courts is notable, analysts argue that the most consequential element lies in the restructuring of Pakistan’s military, potentially shifting the balance of power between the army, navy, and air force.
Key Changes in the Military Command Structure
A central feature of the amendment is the overhaul of Article 243, which governs the relationship between the civilian government and the armed forces. Key changes include:
- Creation of the Chief of Defence Forces (CDF) post – The army chief, currently Field Marshal Asim Munir, will concurrently hold this position, granting him authority over the Pakistan Air Force (PAF) and Pakistan Navy (PN).
- Abolition of the Chairman Joint Chiefs of Staff Committee (CJCSC) – Traditionally, the CJCSC played a balancing role among the three services. The post, currently held by General Sahir Shamshad Mirza, will be retired at the end of this month.
- Formation of the Commander of National Strategic Command (CNSC) – A new role overseeing Pakistan’s nuclear command, limited to army officers and appointed by the CDF.
- Five-star ranks transformed into constitutional offices – Previously honorary, these ranks now come with lifetime immunity from criminal prosecution, full privileges, and the right to remain in uniform indefinitely.
Under this framework, removing a five-star officer requires a two-thirds parliamentary majority, compared to a simple majority needed to dismiss an elected government.
Field Marshal Asim Munir: Consolidating Military Authority
Field Marshal Asim Munir, elevated to a five-star rank in May 2025, is the second Pakistani officer to achieve this rank after Ayub Khan in the 1960s. With the new amendment, Munir’s dual roles as COAS and CDF could extend at least until 2030, significantly consolidating the army chief’s influence.
Experts like constitutional law scholar Reema Omer warn that this concentration of power, combined with lifetime immunity, risks undermining rule of law and civilian oversight.
Historical Context: Army Dominance in Pakistan
Since Pakistan’s independence in 1947, the army has been the most influential institution in national governance. With four military coups and decades of political interference, the COAS has often been considered the country’s most powerful figure, overshadowing elected leaders.
Despite promises of reform by Munir’s predecessor, General Qamar Javed Bajwa, critics argue that the military’s grip on state institutions has only strengthened. The 27th Amendment comes just six months after a brief conflict with India, which some analysts, including Professor Aqil Shah, suggest provided the impetus for the army’s expanded authority.
Diverging Opinions on the Amendment
Supporters, including State Minister Aqeel Malik, claim the reform enhances national security coordination, modernizes military command, and ensures swift responses to emerging threats. Former Vice Admiral Ahmed Saeed adds that the changes aim to align Pakistan’s command structure with 21st-century multi-domain warfare, arguing that the amendment clarifies roles rather than concentrating power.
Critics, however, caution that the amendment risks creating institutional imbalances. Former generals and security analysts warn that the PAF and PN may lose autonomy over strategic planning and senior promotions, potentially eroding cohesion among the services.
Majid Nizami, a security analyst based in Lahore, notes:
“Separate appointments for the CDF and the army chief would have strengthened institutional synergy. The current model risks consolidating dominance rather than enhancing coordination.”
Pakistan’s Nuclear Command and Strategic Concerns
The amendment codifies the army’s oversight of Pakistan’s nuclear programme, including research, development, and deployment. While the Strategic Plans Division (SPD) has historically managed operational control, the formalization under the amendment underscores the army’s de facto influence.
Saeed, however, emphasizes that the civilian government retains a degree of constitutional oversight, though critics remain skeptical about transparency and checks on military authority.
Political Implications and Public Debate
The reform has sparked concerns of a “constitutional surrender” by political parties to the military, with critics claiming it institutionalizes army supremacy over the ballot box. Munir’s rising public profile, highlighted by international visits including meetings with Donald Trump, has fueled speculation that the army chief may play a central role in shaping Pakistan’s political landscape.
Former Prime Minister Imran Khan, imprisoned since 2023, has accused Munir of orchestrating a crackdown on his party, Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), though the military denies such claims.
Analysts like Shah argue that the ruling PML-N government may have supported the amendment to secure political stability in the face of opposition pressure, particularly from the PTI.
Conclusion: Strengthening or Destabilizing Pakistan’s Military Balance?
The 27th Constitutional Amendment represents a historic turning point in Pakistan’s civil-military relations. While proponents argue it modernizes the military, ensures strategic coordination, and prepares Pakistan for 21st-century warfare, critics contend it consolidates army dominance, threatens service autonomy, and risks political and institutional imbalance.
The ultimate impact of these reforms on Pakistan’s national security, civilian governance, and regional stability will likely unfold over the next several years, making this one of the most closely watched developments in the country’s contemporary history.
Leave a Reply