Antoine Semenyo’s arrival at Manchester City is already reshaping the club’s attacking landscape. Just two games into his City career, the £62.5m signing from Bournemouth has delivered two goals and one assist, immediately justifying Pep Guardiola’s decision to invest heavily in the 26-year-old forward during the January transfer window.
From a dream debut in the FA Cup to a crucial strike in the Carabao Cup semi-final first leg against Newcastle, Semenyo has wasted no time in making his presence felt. His performances have sparked debate across the Premier League: who benefits most from his signing—and who stands to lose out?
Instant Impact at the Etihad
Semenyo announced himself in emphatic fashion with a goal and an assist in City’s 10–1 demolition of Exeter City in the FA Cup third round. While the opposition were lower-league, the confidence and sharpness he displayed caught the eye.
He followed that up with an even more significant contribution at St James’ Park, scoring the opening goal against holders Newcastle United in a hostile atmosphere. He later found the net again, only for the goal to be controversially ruled out after a prolonged VAR review, before City sealed a 2–0 victory late on.
For a player still adapting to Guardiola’s famously complex system, the speed of his integration has been remarkable.
“The whole environment here is perfect,” Semenyo said after the match.
“Everyone is confident and wanting to achieve the best. They helped with my confidence and made me feel welcome.”
What Semenyo Brings to Manchester City
Semenyo describes himself as “powerful, quick and strong”—attributes that add a different dimension to City’s often intricate, possession-heavy attack. Crucially, he also prides himself on being clinical, a trait Guardiola values deeply as City chase domestic and European silverware.
The Ghana international is comfortable playing anywhere across the front three, giving City tactical flexibility and a direct option alongside the creativity of Phil Foden and the flair of Rayan Cherki.
His Premier League pedigree is undeniable. Before his move, Semenyo had scored 10 league goals for Bournemouth this season, placing him among the division’s most productive attackers.
Winners
Manchester City and Pep Guardiola
City are the immediate winners. For much of the season, the goalscoring burden has rested almost exclusively on Erling Haaland, who has scored an astonishing 39 goals in 34 games for club and country.
However, Haaland has endured a rare dip in form recently, managing just one goal in his past six appearances and failing to score from open play since December.
Semenyo’s arrival eases that pressure. His ability to score from wide areas and attack defenders directly offers City an alternative route to goal—something Guardiola’s side can occasionally lack against deep defensive blocks.
City captain Bernardo Silva praised both Semenyo’s talent and character:
“He looks not just a very good player but also a very good guy, which fits right in with the team.”
Erling Haaland
Haaland himself stands to benefit significantly. Semenyo provides a new source of assists and movement around him, stretching defences and creating space in central areas.
With defences no longer able to focus solely on stopping Haaland, City’s attack becomes more unpredictable—and more dangerous.
Manchester City’s Title Challenge
Premier League leaders Arsenal may also feel the ripple effect. Holding a six-point lead at the summit, they now face a Manchester City side that has strengthened mid-season—something Guardiola’s teams are notorious for capitalising on.
Semenyo’s finishing ability could prove decisive in tight title-race matches where fine margins matter most.
A Bit of Both: Bournemouth
For Bournemouth, Semenyo’s departure is bittersweet.
On the positive side, the club have secured a huge profit, having signed him for just £10m from Bristol City three years ago. His sale contributes to an estimated £250m in transfer income since last summer, underlining Bournemouth’s reputation for smart recruitment and selling at peak value.
However, the Cherries have now lost another key player after already seeing Dean Huijsen, Illia Zabarnyi, Milos Kerkez and Dango Ouattara depart.
Manager Andoni Iraola will have funds to reinvest, but replacing Semenyo’s goals, power, and consistency will be no easy task.
Losers
Manchester United
Perhaps the biggest losers are Manchester United.
Semenyo had been strongly linked with a move to Old Trafford, but instead joined their fiercest rivals. To compound matters, United recently sacked head coach Ruben Amorim, appointing Michael Carrick as interim boss.
Carrick’s first match in charge comes in the Manchester derby, where Semenyo could make his Premier League debut for City—this time wearing sky blue instead of red, after already hurting United earlier in the season.
Arsenal’s Rivals
Arsenal may be leading the league, but City’s reinforcement adds pressure. Semenyo’s presence strengthens a squad already packed with quality and experience in title run-ins.
City’s Fringe Wingers
Not everyone inside City’s squad benefits.
With Semenyo arriving, competition on the right wing intensifies. Oscar Bobb and Savinho now face uncertain futures.
- Bobb, 22, has struggled with injuries and is reportedly attracting interest from Borussia Dortmund.
- Savinho, signed for £31m from Girona, has contributed just two goals and three assists in 23 appearances, raising questions about his long-term role under Guardiola.
With Guardiola judging attackers primarily on output, squad reshuffles—either this January or in the summer—appear increasingly likely.
What Comes Next?
Semenyo could hit another milestone on Saturday if he makes his Premier League debut in the Manchester derby at Old Trafford. Given his early form, few would bet against him making an immediate impact once again.
For Manchester City, his arrival looks like a statement of intent. For rivals, it is a warning. And for Semenyo himself, this is shaping up to be the perfect platform to take his career to the very highest level.
Leave a Reply